CURRENT INITIATIVES

COURT HOLDS.

When Dogs Get Caught in the Legal System

When dogs become part of a cruelty, neglect, or dangerous-dog case, they can spend months—or even years—in shelters waiting for the legal process to play out.

While the courts determine what happens next, the dogs wait. Some may spend much of that time in kennels, with limited opportunities to experience life outside the shelter.

But how often does this happen? How long are dogs actually held? What happens to them afterward? And what about dogs who spend months confined, only to be euthanized when their cases finally end?

There’s a financial cost, too. Housing and caring for dogs during lengthy legal proceedings can be expensive. Who pays those bills—owners, shelters, or taxpayers? And how much of that expense could be avoided if cases were resolved more quickly?

NCAG is working to answer these questions by examining court-hold practices, confinement periods, outcomes, and costs in Colorado.

Our goal is to identify ways to protect dogs’ well-being without compromising public safety or due process. That could mean resolving cases more quickly, exploring appropriate alternatives to shelter confinement, or improving how decisions about a dog’s future are made.

Dogs shouldn’t have to spend more time confined than necessary simply because their cases are unresolved.

Court Holds | Zion's Story: 17 Months in Limbo |

Zion was a dog from Parker, Colorado, with a documented history of dangerous encounters involving other dogs. His behavior raised legitimate public safety concerns, and a court ordered that he be euthanized. His owner challenged that decision, setting off a lengthy legal battle that left Zion at the Dumb Friends League’s Buddy Center in Castle Rock for approximately 17 months.

While the humans involved argued over his fate, Zion remained confined. For nearly a year and a half, his future was uncertain, and the costs continued to mount. His owner reportedly estimated spending $48,000 in legal and boarding expenses.

In March 2024, a court authorized Zion’s release under certain conditions, and he was reunited with his owner in Oregon the following month. But that resolution raises questions of its own. How would compliance with those conditions be monitored in another state? What safeguards were in place to protect other animals and people? And what happened to Zion afterward?

Zion’s case illustrates a difficult reality: prolonged legal proceedings can affect both canine welfare and public safety, regardless of whether a dog is ultimately released or euthanized.

The question isn’t simply whether a dog should live or die. It’s whether we can make those decisions fairly, responsibly, and without unnecessary delays that may prolong suffering.

PAST INITIATIVES

2025 PACFA Sunset Review: Who's Watching the Watchdogs?

Colorado’s Pet Animal Care and Facilities Act (PACFA) regulates shelters, rescues, breeders, and other pet animal facilities. Its purpose is to protect animals by establishing standards of care and overseeing the facilities responsible for them.

But how do we know whether the program is actually working?

When PACFA came up for sunset review in 2025, NCAG examined its inspection practices, enforcement, and accountability. We found troubling gaps between what the program was intended to accomplish and what the available evidence could tell us about its effectiveness.

We advocated for a meaningful evaluation of PACFA’s performance before extending the program for another 15 years. Instead, the legislature renewed it for eight years without requiring the comprehensive performance evaluation we had sought.

In 2026, we took the next step, requesting a legislative performance audit. That effort ended in a tie vote, leaving the audit request unsuccessful.

Although the sunset review and audit effort have concluded, the underlying questions remain. Are regulated facilities meeting appropriate standards of care? Is enforcement effective? And how can Colorado demonstrate that its regulatory program is actually improving animal welfare?

Regulation alone doesn’t guarantee protection. We need evidence that it’s working.

Read more about NCAG’s PACFA research and advocacy.

EMAIL

info@canineadvocacy.org

PHONE

(720) 443-1084

FACEBOOK

canineadvocates

EMAIL

info@canineadvocacy.org

PHONE

(720) 443-1084

FACEBOOK

canineadvocates